Unified Slider/Dial Control (auto-morph by shape, preserve mappings)
under review
Ven Beatbox
Description:
Unify
sliders and dials
into a single Continuous Control
that auto-morphs
its presentation based on widget shape/orientation: tall = vertical slider, wide = horizontal slider, square ≈ dial
. The control keeps the same ID, mappings, actions, and ranges
regardless of presentation, with an optional lock to force a chosen style.Problem:
Currently, sliders and dials are treated as different widgets, so changing layout (e.g., making a slider more square) often means
rebuilding or re-mapping
to switch to a dial—and vice versa. This duplicates work, breaks consistency, and slows iteration for dense, responsive layouts.Proposed Solution:
- One Control, Three Presentations:A singleContinuous Controlrenders as
-
Vertical slider
when height ≫ width, -
Horizontal slider
when width ≫ height, -
Dial
when aspect is near-square
(threshold user-settable, e.g., 0.85–1.15). - Preserve Everything:Samemidi/osc mappings, actions, ranges/min-max, step/curve, ramp/quantize guards, and visual style regardless of presentation. No re-assignment needed.
- Lock & Overrides:OptionalStyle Lock(Slider-V / Slider-H / Dial) to prevent auto-morph for users who prefer fixed visuals; project/page defaults.
- Smart Gestures:
- Linear/fine-adjust drag for all presentations;
circular + linear
drag for dials. - Optional accel for long throws; scrubbing with modifier keys; double-tap to reset.
- Inspector Controls:Aspect threshold, pointer angle range for dial, tick/indicator options, value readout mode, snap points.
- Copy/Duplicate Safety:Duplicates retain the same control type and presentation logic; resizing triggers morph without breaking bindings.
- Themes & Accessibility:Contrast guard, large-type readouts, color-blind-safe indicators; pictogram/Genmoji labels supported.
Benefits:
- No re-mappingwhen switching between slider and dial looks.
- Faster, cleaner page design: layout drives look, function stays identical.
- Consistent behavior across devices/orientations while preserving muscle memory.
- Less widget proliferation; simpler templates and maintenance.
Examples:
- A volume control grid is resized to fit a tight matrix; square cells automatically render as dialswithout losing MIDI learns.
- Sound-design page: widen Cutoff to become a horizontal sliderfor precision, then shrink to square for adial—all mappings intact.
- Duplicate a control to a second page; it appears as a vertical slideron a tall strip and adialin a compact header, yet both share the same actions and ranges.
This summary was automatically generated by GPT-5.1 Thinking on 2025-11-21.
ultracello
marked this post as
under review
Ven Beatbox
ultracello I am very sorry for the inconvenience, and I know it's ChatGPT generated,but the post suggests EXACTLY the contrary !!
Sliders and dials SHOULD be coupled as they are currently not ! (there are 2 different "buttons" for the same concept)
I suggested vertical and horizontal sliders turn into a circular dial when in a square shape !
Peace
ultracello
Ven Beatbox: Hey, could you please check again the updated version? Add further details if something is missing or wrong.
Ven Beatbox
ultracello waouw ! That's quite nice !
The "locking orientation" idea is a remarkable add-on to the idea...
Well I don't have to say anything more.
Just one more thing, (I think I might have to re-post another thread into another feedback entry)..
On my original post, I talked about letting a horizontal clip to be possible (currently, the clips loaded with audio are round or horizontal, but never vertical)
Should I post another feedback request for this ?
Thank you again
Ven Beatbox
The benefit would be : not having to manually re-attribute all the functions set up when changing from a vertical/horizontal slider to a dial and vice-versa (while they perform technically the exact same function).